BUYING GUIDE: CHOOSING YOUR BARBECUE

Written by the BMR technical team

Choosing from the available barbecues mainly depends on the desired type of cooking, the frequency of use, the number of people to feed, and the available space. Between gas, charcoal, pellet barbecues, and smokers, each option presents advantages and constraints.

This buying guide explains how to choose the right barbecue according to your usage, detailing the differences between fuels, the technical criteria to check, and good maintenance practices to ensure a long life for the appliance.

Which type of barbecue to choose based on your needs

Gas Barbecue

Gas barbecues run on propane or natural gas. They allow for quick lighting and precise temperature control. They are suitable for both direct and indirect cooking and require little preparation before use. The smoky flavour is less pronounced than with charcoal, but cooking consistency is high.

Charcoal Barbecue 

Charcoal barbecues use briquettes or natural charcoal as fuel. They are known for providing a distinct smoky flavour and high temperatures for searing. Lighting takes longer, and heat management requires more attention and experience. 

Barbecue au gaz en fonctionnement avec poulet et steaks en cuisson sur la grille.Barbecue au gaz en fonctionnement avec poulet et steaks en cuisson sur la grille.

Pellet Barbecue

Pellet barbecues use compressed wood pellets fed by a motorized system. They allow for precise and stable cooking, ideal for smoking and slow cooking. The taste varies depending on the type of wood used. This type of barbecue requires an electrical power source.

Smoker 

Smokers are primarily designed for low-temperature cooking over long periods. They are used to smoke meats, fish, and cheeses. There are electric, propane, charcoal, and pellet smokers. They are less versatile for quick cooking.

Barbecue à granules sur pattes avec trémie latérale et contrôle numérique intégré.Barbecue à granules sur pattes avec trémie latérale et contrôle numérique intégré.
Comparison table of main barbecue types
Type Lighting Temperature control Smoky flavor Versatility Preparation time
Gas Very fast High Low to moderate High Short
Charcoal Slow Medium High Medium Long
Pellet Fast Very high Moderate to high High Short
Smoker Variable High High Low Long

Gas

Lighting
Very fast
Temperature control
High
Smoky flavor
Low to moderate
Versatility
High
Preparation time
Short

Charcoal

Lighting
Slow
Temperature control
Medium
Smoky flavor
High
Versatility
Medium
Preparation time
Long

Pellet

Lighting
Fast
Temperature control
Very high
Smoky flavor
Moderate to high
Versatility
High
Preparation time
Short

Smoker

Lighting
Variable
Temperature control
High
Smoky flavor
High
Versatility
Low
Preparation time
Long

Items to check when buying

Before purchasing, check the elements that directly influence the barbecue's durability and cooking stability.

  • Firebox: prioritize a rigid material (steel, enameled cast iron, or stainless steel) with sufficient thickness to prevent deformation under heat.
  • Lid: it must close properly to retain heat and ensure even cooking.
  • Thermometer: a model built into the lid allows you to monitor the temperature without opening the barbecue.
  • Ignition system: must be simple, reliable, and protected from moisture.

Type of grates

Barbecues are equipped with grates made from different materials, which influences heat retention, durability, and maintenance.

There are metal grates (porcelain-enameled or not), cast iron (enameled or not), and stainless steel, often designed with wide and closely spaced rods to better hold food. Enameled cast iron and stainless steel grates are generally recommended because they resist corrosion better. Stainless steel grates may, however, brown over time without affecting cooking performance.

Uncoated cast iron grates require more maintenance. They must be oiled regularly to prevent oxidation and are cleaned cold, unlike stainless steel grates. 

The cooking surface varies by model. It is estimated that approximately 60 sq.in. per person allows food to be cooked without overloading the grate. The type of grate influences barbecue performance based on use.

Grille de barbecue au charbon avec flammes visibles et ustensiles en acier posés dessus.Grille de barbecue au charbon avec flammes visibles et ustensiles en acier posés dessus.

Burners

Burners play a central role in heat distribution and cooking quality. For uniform heat, they must cover as much of the firebox as possible.

Most barbecues are equipped with a heat diffuser, whose role is to distribute heat and limit residue buildup. Some models also use protection bars to keep juices and fats away from the burners, thereby reducing the risk of flare-ups, a factor to consider when the barbecue is installed near a building. 

It is recommended to choose an appliance offering at least two burner controls, which allows for the creation of different temperature zones. Some models also offer a sear burner to quickly reach a high temperature, a side burner for pot cooking, or a rotisserie system for cooking poultry.

Brûleurs de barbecue au gaz allumés montrant des flammes bleues alignées.Brûleurs de barbecue au gaz allumés montrant des flammes bleues alignées.

BTU

The power of a gas barbecue is expressed in BTU (British Thermal Unit). However, a high number of BTUs does not guarantee better performance on its own.

Total power often depends on the number of burners. Too many BTUs relative to the cooking surface makes low-heat cooking difficult, while insufficient power slows down the cooking process.

To correctly interpret power, it must be related to the cooking surface. As a guide, the target is approximately 110 BTU per square inch of cooking surface, which achieves a good balance between searing and heat control. Most gas barbecues offer a total power ranging between 24,000 and 60,000 BTU.

Main ouvrant la valve d’une bonbonne de propane pour alimentation d’un barbecue.Main ouvrant la valve d’une bonbonne de propane pour alimentation d’un barbecue.

Conseils d'entretien

Regular maintenance helps extend the lifespan of the barbecue and maintain safe cooking conditions.

  • After each use, clean the grates with a brush to avoid damaging the protective finish.
  • Cast iron grates should be oiled regularly to prevent oxidation.
    To remove rust from the grates, rub them with linseed oil using a dry cloth.
  • Black soap can also be used.
  • Several times during the season, remove accumulated residue from the firebox and the heat plate, as it can ignite and accelerate burner deterioration.
  • If the barbecue is equipped with lava rocks, they should be replaced annually.
  • In the fall, cover the barbecue with a protective cover and, if possible, store it in a dry place.

If indoor storage is not possible, remove the burners and take out the grates. Once clean and completely dry, store them in a paper bag inside the house to limit exposure to moisture.

Nettoyage d’une grille de barbecue avec une éponge au-dessus d’un bac d’eau rouge à l’extérieur.Nettoyage d’une grille de barbecue avec une éponge au-dessus d’un bac d’eau rouge à l’extérieur.

So, ready to buy your barbecue?

Shop our barbecues and accessories online or visit your BMR dealer for more advice.

Common questions: choosing a barbecue

What is the average lifespan of a well-maintained barbecue?
A properly maintained barbecue can last for several years. Durability mainly depends on the quality of the materials, regular maintenance, and protection against moisture.
Can a propane barbecue be converted to natural gas?
Certain models can be converted using a kit designed for this purpose. The conversion must always be carried out in accordance with the manufacturer's recommendations and current standards.
Is a built-in barbecue more durable than a cart model?
No. Durability depends primarily on the quality of the firebox, the burners, and maintenance, regardless of the barbecue's format.
What is a hot plate (griddle) used for on a barbecue?
A hot plate allows you to cook delicate or small-sized foods that could fall through the grates, such as vegetables or seafood. It can also be used to keep food warm.

Last updated: March 2026

Popular barbecues

Shop by category